What to Do When You Have Too Many Ideas

Willa Cather had more stories in her head than she could ever write—but instead of chasing every spark, she made a radical choice: she stopped. She knew that an idea, on its own, is worthless unless you commit to it. If your mind is overflowing with possibilities but you struggle to follow through, the problem isn’t creativity—it’s decision paralysis. The difference between collectors and creators isn’t talent. It’s the willingness to choose one idea and bring it to life.

---

The Myth of Infinite Potential

In 1922, Willa Cather did something that would horrify the modern creative mindset: she refused to start a new book. It wasn’t because she lacked ideas—she had more than she could ever bring to life. But she understood something that most creatives struggle with: an idea, on its own, is nothing. It does not count until you commit.

If your mind is a sprawling archive of half-finished projects, abandoned drafts, and ideas pulling you in every direction, you are not unfocused. You are creative. And the paradox of creativity is this: the more you engage with it, the more ideas you generate. The real challenge isn’t coming up with ideas—it’s choosing the right one. Because at some point, you must decide: Will I be a collector, or will I be a creator?

Why You Keep Collecting Ideas (Instead of Acting on Them)

A 2019 study in Nature Communications found that the brain prioritizes novelty. The dopamine system—the part of the brain that governs motivation—responds more strongly to new information than to repeated experiences. This is why the thrill of a fresh idea always feels more intoxicating than the slow, difficult work of execution.

It’s also why, in a world of infinite content, we have never had more access to inspiration—and yet, committing to a single idea feels harder than ever. Every time you scroll past an interesting article, a thought-provoking quote, or a beautiful image, it sparks possibility. But without a process for filtering and refining ideas, they accumulate like digital clutter, overwhelming instead of inspiring you.

The problem isn’t that you have too many ideas. The problem is that you don’t have a system for choosing which ones deserve your energy.

The Three Types of Creative Ideas (And How to Identify the Right One)

Not all ideas are equal. Some are fleeting, some are foundational, and some are just well-disguised procrastination. The key is learning to separate the signal from the noise.

1. The Spark Idea (Short-Lived Excitement)

High energy, but fades fast.

Some ideas feel electric in the moment but lose their appeal once the dopamine wears off. These are often reactive—born from trends, external influence, or fleeting inspiration that lacks depth.

Ask yourself: Do I still care about this idea a week later?

If the answer is no, let it go.

2. The Foundation Idea (Deep, Long-Term Pull)

The ones that won’t leave you alone.

These ideas don’t always feel thrilling at first, but they linger. They resurface. They feel essential to your creative identity. They might not be the easiest ideas, but they are the ones with the most substance.

Ask yourself: Would I still want to explore this idea in five years?

If yes, this belongs in your long-term creative framework.

3. The Avoidance Idea (A Distraction Disguised as Inspiration)

The tempting exit strategy.

Some ideas don’t appear because they’re good. They appear because your brain is looking for an excuse to not do the hard work. These ideas often feel urgent, but they’re really a form of creative resistance.

Ask yourself: Am I genuinely excited about this idea, or am I using it to avoid something difficult?

If the latter, put it aside. Return to what matters.

How to Choose the Right Idea (A Simple Framework)

If you are drowning in ideas but struggling to execute, you need a system—a way to filter out the distractions and commit to what actually matters.

Try the Rule of Three:

Do I care enough about this to work on it for six months? (If not, it’s likely a Spark Idea—file it away and move on.) Does this idea align with my larger creative vision? (If not, it’s an Avoidance Idea—stop using it as an excuse to start over.) Does this idea have enough depth to sustain execution? (If not, let it incubate until it becomes fully formed.)

If an idea passes all three filters, it deserves your focus. Everything else is just noise.

What to Do With the Ideas You’re Not Pursuing (Yet)

One of the biggest fears creatives have about letting go of ideas is the fear of losing them forever. But not every idea needs immediate action. Some need time—time to develop, time to evolve, time to find their true form.

How to Keep Ideas Without Letting Them Overwhelm You

• Create an “Idea Archive” – A single, structured place where unused ideas live. A Notion database, a notebook, a document titled Not Yet.
• Schedule Idea Reviews – Every few months, go through your archive and see what still resonates. You’ll often find that the best ideas return when they’re ready.
• Trust That Ideas Will Return – The best ideas have a way of resurfacing at the right time. If something truly matters, you won’t lose it.

The Hard Truth: Execution is the Difference Between Creators and Collectors

There is a moment in every creative life when you must make a choice: will you chase every new idea, or will you commit to the ones that matter most?

Collecting ideas is easy. Starting is harder. Finishing is the hardest of all.

But the difference between those who create and those who merely collect is not talent. It is not intelligence. It is the willingness to choose one idea, follow it through, and let the rest go.

The right idea is not the one that feels most exciting in the moment. It is the one you are willing to return to, again and again, until it becomes something real.

Choose one. Start today.